Contact us T +32 (0)2 626 07 20 | info@europeangreens.eu

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Flickr

Donate

  • Login to your account
  • User account
  • About Us
    • Organisation
    • People
    • Networks and Working Groups
    • Guidelines
  • Our Positions
    • Positions
    • Resolutions
    • Policy Papers
    • Manifesto
  • Get involved
    • Climate Action
    • European Green Recovery Campaign
    • European Greens Podcast
    • European Ideas Lab
    • The Green Screen
    • Local Councillors' Network
    • Trans-Inclusive Feminist Campaign
  • Member Parties
  • News
    • News
    • Press Releases
    • Brand Assets
    • Communications Team
  • Events
Home
  • About Us
  • Our Positions
  • Get involved
  • Member Parties
  • News
  • Events
  • Positions
    • Foreign and Security Policy
    • Europe and Democracy
    • Climate and Energy
    • Economy and Jobs
    • Human Rights and Migration
    • Social Justice and Health
    • Environment and Food
  • Resolutions
  • Policy Papers
  • Manifesto

Stop data-retention in Europe!

Share
Share on FacebookShare on Twittershare on Linked Inshare on Google Plusshare via email

Resolution accepted at the 12th EGP Council, Barcelona, Spain, March 19-21, 2010

We, as Greens, are calling on the EU Commission to really go for a comprehensive review of the Directive focussing on effectiveness, necessity and proportionality, also in mind of the EU Charta for Fundamental Rights. We want to start a new approach to end this Directive now, not only in certain member states, but in the whole EU. We want European politics to strengthen civil liberties and the value of privacy as laid out in the European Convention of Human Rights and the EU-Charta for Fundamental Rights, which is now binding due to the Lisbon Treaty.

After the decision of the German Federal Constitutional Court on March 2, 2010, a European discussion started about the future of data retention in the EU. Commissioners Malmström and Reding declared that they want a quick evaluation of the Directive. Since the European Parliament and Council adopted Directive 2006/24/EC, on "the retention of data generated or processed in connection with the provision of publicly available electronic communications services or of public communications networks and amending Directive 2002/58/EC" in 2006, protests and demonstrations demanding „Freedom not fear“ have spoken out against this directive. The protesters all over Europe stated that the surveillance of all European citizens and the storage of personal telecommunication data for at least six months is a violation of human rights, especially the right for privacy and the right of informational self-determination.

Under current regulations on data retention, the telecommunications data of all 450 million EU citizens are retained generally and without a prior suspicion, for the purpose of access for security authorities in the case of severe crimes. This serious encroachment on fundamental rights of all citizens was pushed through one of the fastest legislative procedures in the history of the EU – it took less than three months from the presentation of the Commission’s draft to the vote in Parliament. There was no real debate with data protection bodies and the public, despite Privacy International (PI) and European Digital Rights (EDRI) having collected more than 50.000 signatures against the proposal in a very short time. Additionally, last minute amendments in the plenary by the big groups in the European Parliament sharpened the Committees proposal in central points.

Herewith the principle of the presumption of innocence is virtually on the brink of collapse. Already, lawyers are talking about the emergence of a police state because of the fact that private telecommunications networks and companies are forced to structure their technical installations to suit security policies. The fact that there has been no real necessity is largely ignored. According to the German Federal Criminal Police Office’s own figures, a lack of telecommunications data led to a crime not being solved in less than 0.01 % of cases. In contrast, the ever-increasing accumulation of data is a disproportionate encroachment on the individual’s rights and gives rise to further security risks as the danger of misuse and unauthorized disclosure is always lurking in these data stockpiles. The anti-terrorist strategy that you can find a needle in a haystack by increasing the size of the haystack has long been proved to be an illusion.

Those interested in reducing the crime rate, and thus effectively combating serious crimes and terrorism, must turn their backs on the symbolic gestures of experimental politicians and concentrate on the difficult challenges posed by important societal problems. Therefore the alternative security policy that the Greens are pursuing is aimed at combating all the dangers faced by people and the environment in whatever area.

As Greens – in Europe and worldwide – we know how important binding and enforceable citizens’ rights are for a functioning democracy. This holds true for the analogue world as well as for the digital world. The German Court ruling stated that the German Implementation Act violates the constitution and all data has to be deleted immediately. Not only the German Federal Constitutional Court and a huge part of German civil society is against data retention. Due to court rulings, the implementation of the data retention Directive was limited or even stopped in other countries as well, like in Romania where the Constitutional Court stopped the Directive. This is one reason that till now, six countries still have not implemented the Directive into national law. The approach of Commissioners Malmström and Reding for an evaluation of data retentionaffirms the broad criticism of data retention in Europe. We, as Greens, are calling on the EU Commission to really go for a comprehensive review of the Directive focussing on effectiveness, necessity and proportionality, also in mind of the EU Charta for Fundamental Rights. We want to start a new approach to end this Directive now, not only in certain member states, but in the whole EU. We want European politics to strengthen civil liberties and the value of privacy as laid out in the European Convention of Human Rights and the EU-Charta for Fundamental Rights, which is now binding due to the Lisbon Treaty.

Since the coming into force of the Lisbon Treaty, we can see, that the European Parliament takes responsibility of the EU-citizen rights in the several processes going on at EU level. From the so called „SWIFT agreement“ with the United States, via the collection and exchange of Passengers Name Records (PNR), to the secretly negotiated “Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement” (ACTA) – the Parliament made clear, that the protection of privacy and the rule of law is of upmost importance. The policy of broad surveillance of private, social and work life has to end. We want a Europe of freedom, that respects and defends civil liberties. For this, the European approach on the struggle against the blanket retention of personal data has to be fought also in the member states parliaments. In the new Europe of Lisbon we have to act together!

The European Greens, together with other movements, want to lay the foundations for a policy U-turn that will free us from the psyche of a society of fear and lead us into a Union where law is supreme and there is recognition of the causes of danger and that with the engagement of the people these can be minimized. In view of the present mood and the conservative parliamentary majorities this will be an enormous challenge but we Greens are the right people to take this on.

Therefore as European Greens, we want:

−to abolish the blanket logging of our communications and locations (data retention) −to strengthen the protests against data retention and new forms like PNR. We want to play a vital role in cooperation with our civil society partners. −that the EU-Commission stops data retention in Europe and make a turnaround in their policies to more privacy and respect of civil liberties. −to use the new power of the European Parliament after the Lisbon Treaty, to stop security measures like the proposed PNR- and SWIFT-agreements, in which the whole population is set under a general suspicion while data protection principles and juridical redress aren’t assured

−to strengthen the work and independence of the European Data Protection Supervisor and focus on an EU approach for modern and binding European and international high standards for data protection.

−to start a debate on the general question of fundamental rights in the field of police and security measures in all parliaments in the EU – the European Parliament and the parliaments in the EU member states

 

Download the complete resolution in PDF format here...

Recent News

Icon:
Title:

Europe Day: Europe must go green!

Post date:
09 May 2023
Body:

73 years ago, on 9 May 1950, the Schuman declaration marked the beginning of the most ambitious peace project on the continent, a project aimed at making war in Europe "not merely unthinkable, but materially impossible". Today, we celebrate the peace and unity that we have managed to secure in the European Union over the past decades. 

Icon:
Title:

Building a stronger social Europe: Sara Matthieu talks EU Minimum Income on Labour Day

Post date:
28 April 2023
Body:

At every level, from local governments to the European Parliament, Greens promote legislation that improves working conditions and reduces inequality. In our interview with Green MEP Sara Matthieu we discuss the Minimum Income initiative which aims to ensure that no one in the EU must live below the poverty line.

Icon:
European Green Party Co-Chairs Mélanie Vogel and Thomas Waitz
Title:

One year since the full-scale illegal invasion of Ukraine

Post date:
24 February 2023
Body:

Today marks one year since the full-scale illegal invasion of Ukraine by Russian President Vladimir Putin’s forces. Since this day, Putin has continued to violate international laws and agreements as well as the human rights of the people of Ukraine. 

More News

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Flickr
Tweet Contents:

RT @BenniDeMarte: And it's about to staaaaaart! #egpcongress

Tweet Author:
europeangreens
Creation Date:
49 min ago
Tweet Contents:

RT @GreensEFA: Great news💜

The EP voted with a big majority on proposals to combat #SexualHarassment in the EU & EU Parliament.

Sexual…

Tweet Author:
europeangreens
Creation Date:
1 hour ago
Tweet Contents:

🥳 We are hydrated, caffeinated and motivated to kick off the #EGPCongress in Vienna today!

🫶 We are excited to meet you all in person. And if you can’t attend, don’t miss the live stream of the opening session at 13:30 CET.

https://t.co/GTyYCaeRhj https://t.co/vDfGB3TeNV

Tweet Author:
europeangreens
Creation Date:
3 hours ago

Sign up to our newsletter

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Fill in the blank.

Take charge of your future. Donate Green.

Chip in today to help us build a Greener Europe!

Donate

  • Organisation
    • About
    • History
    • Councils
    • Congresses
    • Finance Advisory Board
    • Amendments Committee
    • Conciliation Panel
  • People
    • Committee
    • Team
    • Vacancies
    • Traineeships
  • Networks and Working Groups
    • Networks
      • Balkan
      • Mediterranean
      • Gender
      • tilt!
      • Queer
      • Local Councillors
      • Seniors
      • Disability
    • Working Groups
      • Foreign and Security Policy
      • Future of Europe
      • Trade
  • Guidelines
    • Charter
    • Statutes
    • Rulebook
    • Finances
    • Privacy Policy
  • Our Positions
    • Positions
    • Resolutions
    • Policy Papers
    • Manifesto
  • Member Parties
  • News
    • News
    • Press Releases
    • Brand Assets
    • Communications Team
  • Events
  • Campaigns
    • The Green Screen
    • Green Talking Heads
    • Trans-Inclusive Feminist Campaign
    • Climate Action for the People and the Planet
    • European Green Recovery Campaign
  • Donate
Home

Rue du Taciturne 34

B-1000 Brussels, Belgium

T +32 (0) 2 626 07 20

info@europeangreens.eu

© European Greens - With the financial support of the European Parliament. Sole liability remains with the author.

cookies