Contact us T +32 (0)2 626 07 20 | info@europeangreens.eu

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Flickr

Donate

  • Login to your account
  • User account
  • About Us
    • Organisation
    • People
    • Networks and Working Groups
    • Guidelines
  • Our Positions
    • Positions
    • Resolutions
    • Policy Papers
    • Manifesto
  • Member Parties
  • News
    • News
    • Press Releases
    • Brand Assets
    • Communications Team
  • Events
Home
  • About Us
  • Our Positions
  • Member Parties
  • News
  • Events
  • Positions
    • Foreign and Security Policy
    • Europe and Democracy
    • Climate and Energy
    • Economy and Jobs
    • Human Rights and Migration
    • Social Justice and Health
    • Environment and Food
  • Resolutions
  • Policy Papers
  • Manifesto

Put Capitalism on a Green Leash

Share
Share on FacebookShare on Twittershare on Linked Inshare on Google Plusshare via email

Resolution adopted at the Paris Council meeting, 9-12 October 2008.

The last few weeks have witnessed the collapse some of the most powerful banks in the world, the nationalisation of American and European banking institutions, the injection of hundreds of billions of euros of liquidity by central banks and a dramatic downslide of the stock markets. So far, the markets have proved unable to find a solution to the crisis that they created in the first place and to stem its disastrous consequences for the hundreds of thousands of people who will lose their homes or their jobs and for the enterprises confronted with an unprecedented credit crunch. These are just a few of the detrimental effects of financial neo-liberalism.  Hopefully, this will signal the end of the era of financial deregulation that has been pursued by right and left Governments alike since the late 1970s. It is remarkable that 40 years later, some of them still defend the fiction that markets will regulate themselves, optimising processes and ensuring liquidity and that creating wealth for the richest will trickle down and benefit all.

The US and EU must take charge of financial capitalism as it stands today and have to find and implement an adequate regulation system.  However, before we can develop and implement coherent regulations, we must understand the underlying causes of the financial crisis - and these causes are not solely related to finance.  The roots of the problem are to be found in ideologies and conscious political choices which go beyond the financial world.  It must lead to changes in the way financial markets are regulated but also changes in matters regarding (in)equalities, taxation, redistribution of income and the management of the end of the era of cheap petrol.

There are three primary causes of the current crisis.

  1. The first is the deregulation of the financial system which enabled the development of new opaque financial products that had no relation to economic reality, e.g. they were of esoteric value rather than real value.  Furthermore, the prudent rules controlling bank activity were largely by-passed with the blessing of public financial authorities: these banks created products which contained securities originating from subprime credits over which the banks had no control.  Finally, the securitisation which should have reduced the overall risk instead led the banks to enter into even riskier domains. 
  1. The second factor is the massive influx of money into the market.  The sources were:
  • Loans from countries that have grown rich because of their control  of fossil fuels as well as from some threshold economies;
  • The² social protection systems: the massive investment of life insurance and pension funds by the institutions which administered them (insurance companies, institutional funds...)
  • A significant increase in income and property (Austrian amendment) inequalities which allowed the placement of personal fortunes on the market
  • The shifting of income redistribution to the detriment of salaries and capital profits.  Never have the dividends from these organisations been so high.
  1. The third is excessive debt.  In a context of increasing social inequalities, the tension regarding household buying power, low interest rates, notably in the US, increases in property prices and the ever present pressures to consume, household debt has spiralled not only in the US, but also in the UK, Ireland, Spain and other countries.  It is the household debt and credit of the least solvent that have been sold and resold by American banks to other players in the financial markets and have been subsequently sold on, allowing the system to wash its hands of responsibility. 

As a result, vast sums of money are used to buy increasingly high risk credits without any public checks and balances. Austrian amendment: without a proper public system of regulations:

In this context, the EGP puts forward the following propositions for consideration: 

In the short term, Governments have no other choice than to take action in order to prevent the collapse of the banking system by providing state guarantees or injecting capital, using taxpayers' money. Because at the same time, Governments find billions to save banks that are responsible for their problem, while they can’t find the funding needed to fight starvation, unemployment, environmental degradation, the loss of biodiversity and to fund development aid, this rescue is not legitimate if not counterbalanced by a number of measures 

Measures aimed at ensuring the stability and the transparency of the financial system

  • First of all, the compensation of executives and financial traders must be drastically reined in. These were effectively one of the root causes of the current crisis as large banks tried at all costs to artificially inflate the performance of their funds in order to justify the outrageous salaries of their traders.  This encouraged executives to take ill-considered risks when trading credits. From now on, their salaries must be in line with real, sustainable performance.      
  • The long-standing Green proposal of implementing a financial transaction tax (Tobin/Spahn type tax) must urgently be implemented at European level.        
     
  • All financial instruments currently marketed and sold by financial institutions, especially those which enable securitization of loans, must be scrutinized by a Financial Services Testing Foundation, set up at European level. Those whose innocuousness and added value to the economy are questioned have to undergo an extra accreditation procedure.    
  • Similarly, naked short-selling, that is, speculating on the loss of value of assets, must be permanently banned;     
  • The valuation of stocks by the fair value principle (mark to market) has proven to be feeding the crisis and should be reformed;   

  • Initiatives must be taken at European level to effectively tackle the accreditation, transparency and control of hedge funds;         
  • Similarly, increased action must be taken to prevent tax fraud and tax evasion, effectively closing the tax havens within the EU and putting pressure on those outside the EU         .
  • Consideration must be given to measures effectively preventing speculative shareholders to exert control on enterprises (e.g. by imposing delays before their voting rights become effective) 

Measure aimed at improvement of consumer protection      

  • Across the EU, deposits to financial institutions must be guaranteed to a minimum level of 100.000 €; to that effect, a reserve to which all financial institutions shall have to contribute must be established where it does not yet exist;

Measures aimed at improving the regulatory framework   

  • Accounting rules must ensure that the balance sheets and corporate accounts reflect the economic reality, e.g. by drastically restricting the ability of financial institutions to remove key risks from their balance sheets and by moving away from rules that are exclusively based on short-term market value;
  • An initiative must be taken at EU level to institute an independent European rating agency;       
  • Last but not least, the regulatory package must be supported by the creation of an EU-wide financial markets watchdog which will overcome the national fragmentation of banking oversight and be strong enough to enforce regulation:

Measures aimed at diminishing the negative effects on the real economy

  • Coordination on the EU-level on measures to diminish the negative effects of the crisis of the finance sector on the other sectors of the economy.  
  • Anti-cyclical budgetary measures must be taken to master the crisis.  
  • In order to counter the effect of the credit crunch on the enterprises (especially the SMEs) sufficient liquidity must be provided by the European Central Bank. 

Finally, it would also be unethical that those whose action made this collapse possible would escape all consequences of them. Investigations must be launched in order to determine whether the current regulatory framework, however limited, has been infringed upon (especially in terms of transparency) and prosecutions be initiated where applicable.

Politically, at the EU commission level, Commissioner McCreevy has been one of the leading promoters of the deregulation of the financial markets, enjoying the wholehearted support of President Barroso. They bear a heavy responsibility in this collapse and we will do whatever we can to prevent the return of a Barroso/McCreevy commission in 2009.

Conclusions

Taking into account the multinational nature of European banks, it is unlikely that there will be a common European plan regarding finance.  However, it is essential that Member State decisions are coordinated and coherent.  In this respect, the 7 October 2008 decisions of Ecofin are a step in the right direction but do not go far enough.

Beyond these emergency proposals, we must address a series of questions regarding the dominant ideology of liberalism in fiscal and credit matters, the fight against inequality, financing of social protection, etc.  The papers voted by the EGP on the economy (April 2008 in Ljubljana) and on social affairs (October 2008, Montreuil contain proposals which are capable of providing a new European political framework for each Member State.

The financial crisis is a historic opportunity to forge a new way of development which will not be based on maximisation of short term profit, but is rather based on putting Europe and the world on the path of sustainable development, maximising the wellbeing of the entire humanity. Europe must be a leading force in this transformation.  This new direction will give the Greens the momentum to win more votes in the European elections in June 2009.

Related downloads:
AttachmentSize
PDF icon EN69.52 KB

Recent News

Icon:
Title:

Our vision of the Conference on the Future of Europe

Post date:
31 March 2021
Body:

After months of negotiations, an agreement was eventually found between the European Parliament, the European Commission and the Council to start the Conference on the Future of Europe. 

We welcome this long-waited outcome and are now putting all our efforts in making the Conference a successful democratic process that delivers change and drives Europe closer to its citizens.

Icon:
Title:

Climate Action - For the people and the planet

Post date:
19 March 2021
Body:
The EGP is committed to driving climate action towards climate neutrality -- in line with the Paris Agreement goal of keeping global temperature rise to 1.5C. As Greens, we believe that climate action should support Europe’s recovery and help reset us on a path towards a resilient, fair future. Greens are already leading this fight all over Europe and we intend to keep it up.

Learn more about the campaign and check out the action at https://europeangreens.eu/climate-action/


Icon:
Title:

2021 New Year's Reception as a gift of culture

Post date:
28 January 2021
Short title:
2021 New Year's Reception as a gift of culture
Body:

On Wednesday 27 January, members and friends of the European Green Party convened for a virtual New Year's Reception. Traditionally organised in Brussels and gathering mostly local supporters, this year we hosted our Green family from all over Europe. The reception was an opportunity to take stock of the year 2020 in all its unprecedented ways, but also celebrate our green successes. Our host was the talented Polish activist Michał Suchora who navigated through our virtual event taking place in both Brussels and Warsaw. 

More News

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Flickr
Tweet Contents:

RT @GreenPartyMolly: For somebody my age this is indeed depressingly familiar

We know how rapidly violence can escalate in Northern Irelan…

Tweet Author:
europeangreens
Creation Date:
1 day ago
Tweet Contents:

RT @EamonRyan: Fully supportive of our Northern colleagues and the role they are playing in protecting the Good Friday Agreement . More tha…

Tweet Author:
europeangreens
Creation Date:
1 day ago
Tweet Contents:

RT @ClareBaileyGPNI: Today is the day we need to re commit to the full delivery and implementation of the #Belfast #GFA in all its parts, w…

Tweet Author:
europeangreens
Creation Date:
1 day ago

Sign up to our newsletter

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Fill in the blank.

Change Europe, donate Green

Chip in today to help us build a Greener Europe!

Donate

  • Organisation
    • About
    • History
    • Councils
    • Congresses
    • Finance Advisory Board
    • Amendments Committee
    • Conciliation Panel
  • People
    • Committee
    • Team
    • Vacancies
    • Traineeships
  • Networks and Working Groups
    • Networks
      • Balkan
      • Gender
      • tilt!
      • Queer
      • Local Councillors
      • Seniors
    • Working Groups
      • Foreign and Security Policy
      • Future of Europe
      • Trade
  • Guidelines
    • Charter
    • Statutes
    • Rulebook
    • Finances
    • Privacy Policy
  • Our Positions
    • Positions
    • Resolutions
    • Policy Papers
    • Manifesto
  • Member Parties
  • News
    • News
    • Press Releases
    • Brand Assets
    • Communications Team
  • Events
  • Campaigns
    • tilt!
    • 2019 EU election campaign
  • Donate
Home

Rue du Taciturne 34

B-1000 Brussels, Belgium

T +32 (0) 2 626 07 20

info@europeangreens.eu

© European Greens - With the financial support of the European Parliament. Sole liability remains with the author.

cookies